Māori Land Court to determine ownership of Hoteo riverbed

The calabash (or gourd) was valued as a food container, suggesting the Hoteo catchment was treasured as a container or area of an abundance of food resources. Although the wider catchment was not permanently settled by Māori, all the hills, peaks, ridges and waterways were named, showing that tangata whenua had strong associations with the entire catchment. Even the smallest tributaries in the catchment had their own names, giving each a unique identity and mauri (spiritual essence). High points around the catchment provide reference points and boundary markers for local iwi. Tangata whenua still retain associations with these land and waterscape features and the traditions associated with them. Auckland Regional Council 1995.

The future use of the Hōteo River for fishing, recreation and irrigation could rest on a case that will go before the Māori Land Court in Whangarei, possibly next year.

The court is being asked to determine whether the riverbed is Māori customary land and, if is it, whether it belongs to iwi Te Runanga Ngāti Whatua or the Ngāti Manuhiri Settlement Trust.

The 28-kilometre river forms at the confluence of the Whangaripo and Waiwhiu streams, north-east of Wellsford, and is a tributary of the Kaipara Harbour.

It is used for numerous recreational activities including whitebaiting, as well as irrigation. In 2014, consented water extraction for the 405 square kilometre catchment was for more than 1.3 million cubic metres a year, or about 15,400 cubic metres a day.

The Hoteo was identified as a ‘priority catchment’ by Auckland Council in 2014, primarily because of the threat posed by river sedimentation to the harbour’s sea grass beds, and has since been a focus for the Kaipara Moana Remediation programme (formerly the Integrated Kaipara Harbour Management Group).

Te Runanga o Ngāti Whatua chief executive Alan Riwaka says it is too early to speculate on the potential implications of the determinations of the Maori Land Court.

“The exact implications will depend on the nature and detail of the determinations of the court,” he says.

“We have a lot of evidence of ownership and custom and usage of the land bordering the Hōteo River, as well as the river itself – for centuries – which will be set out in evidence for the court.

“There have been a number of previous events and legal precedents that have made it possible for Ngāti Whātua and Ngāti Manuhiri to bring this case. The application was originally lodged for Ngāti Whātua with the Māori Land Court in March last year.”

Kaipara Moana Remediation project manager Willie Wright was not aware of the applications, but was confident they would not affect the programme.

“We work with all landholders – the Crown, mana whenua and private land owners – so I don’t see how the ownership of the river would affect us at all,” he said.

Ngāti Manuhiri chair Mook Hohneck declined to comment.

Copies of the application can be obtained from the Māori Land Court. Anyone who wishes to appear or be heard in relation to the applications, has until February 17 register their interest.

Pouakana River decision
In July this year, the Māori Land Court released its decision on the Mercury NZ v Cairns Pouakani River Bed case, where Mercury, supported by the Attorney-General, sought to strike out an application made by Pouakani hapū relating to the Waikato river bed at Pouakani. Pouakani had applied for an order that the riverbed, which is currently used by Mercury for hydropower generation, is Māori customary land. The July decision means the application can now proceed for determination by the Māori Land Court. The court noted that water ownership is a developing area of law that is intertwined with tikanga elements and should not be struck out. Under British common law, naturally flowing freshwater is not owned by anyone, but is treated as a public good, which is still the legal position in NZ.