Sign In / Register
Kaipara District Council (KDC) is the only Northland council to opt out of the Government’s voluntary Head Start local government reform pathway.
At an extraordinary council meeting on July 15, Kaipara District councillors unanimously voted against supporting the current Head Start options and requested that Kaipara not be included in a regional proposal being developed by the Elected Members Steering Group.
Since the meeting, Whangārei District Council, Far North District Council and Northland Regional Council have all voted to continue developing a Head Start Outline Proposal for submission to the Government by August 9.
The proposed staged model would initially establish two unitary authorities before eventually transitioning to a single Northland-wide council.
At the meeting, Kaipara Mayor Jonathan Larsen said although councillors supported working more closely with neighbouring councils where it benefited residents, they questioned why Kaipara should support amalgamation without clear evidence of better outcomes.
“We are being asked to go down this track for our ratepayers, but we don’t know what we’re even agreeing on if we were to agree,” Larsen said.
He said the process had been rushed, with councils given less than three months to develop proposals. He also noted there was currently no legislation governing either the Head Start process or the Government’s proposed “backstop” reforms.
Instead of amalgamating districts, Larsen said he believed Northland should replace the regional council with three unitary authorities, allowing each district to retain local decision-making while sharing genuinely regional services such as civil defence and catchment management.
“There is no reason that, in Northland with our scale and geography, we couldn’t have three unitary councils,” he said.
Deputy Mayor Gordon Lambeth also questioned whether amalgamation would increase costs. He said the Morrison Low Advisory Head Start options analysis found no clear evidence that previous council mergers had delivered financial savings.
Former mayor and councillor Craig Jepson said Northland “doesn’t need a super council”, arguing that amalgamation would create “a distant bureaucratic, debt-laden entity” that weakened rural communities while repeating mistakes seen elsewhere.
Results from a recent Kaipara District Council survey of 263 residents about the proposed amalgamation showed 33.5 per cent of people favoured retaining Kaipara as a standalone unitary authority by transferring Northland Regional Council’s functions to the district council, while 32.3 per cent supported a single Northland-wide unitary authority. A further 20.9 per cent selected “other” options. In the survey, respondents were able to select more than one option. When asked about the issues that were the most important should local government reform go ahead, 82.1 per cent of respondents cited keeping costs affordable for ratepayers as the top priority.
Councillor Rachel Williams noted during the meeting that respondents had not been provided with detailed information about debt, financial impacts or local representation before completing the survey.
In a joint statement issued after all four councils had met, Whangārei District Council, Far North District Council and Northland Regional Council confirmed they would continue developing the proposal, while Kaipara requested that it not be included.
Should a proposal be approved by Government, it would be subject to further analysis, detailed design and public consultation in late 2026 and early 2027, the councils stated.
