Waste Management (WM) has released the results of consultation on the future of Redvale Landfill. In the report it highlighted strong opposition from the Dairy Flat community to the continued use of the site until the mid-2030s, amid ongoing social, environmental, and health concerns.
The consultation ran from March 17 to May 11, and sought public input on proposed solutions to address the looming gap between the scheduled closure of Redvale Landfill in December 2028 and the proposed opening of the Auckland Regional Landfill (ARL) at Wayby next to the Dome Valley around 2036. (Hibiscus Matters, June 2, 2025)
However, despite an extensive Auckland-wide engagement campaign run by WM, the community response was limited, with only 111 written submissions and nine oral submissions received.
- WM proposed four interim waste management options:
- Rebalancing existing landfills
- Identifying a new landfill
- Implementing alternative waste disposal technologies
- Increasing waste recovery and recycling rates
WM said its preferred approach after consultation is to pursue Option 1 (rebalancing existing landfills) and Option 4 (increasing recovery), stating it “appears most workable at this stage” because it could be delivered within the required timeframe, used existing infrastructure, provides operational certainty while longer-term solutions are developed, and had been independently assessed as lower-risk than untested alternatives.
However, the bulk of submitters (73) had responded with “Option 1 – not Redvale.” This indicated that they supported Option 1 but not the renewal of the resource consent at Redvale Landfill, said Redvale Environmental Protection Society chair, Nick de Witte.
Submitters expressed the opinion that the Dairy Flat area had already contributed extensively to Auckland’s waste management solutions and that they were frustrated by the proposed extension. Key concerns raised by residents included consistent odour issues, traffic congestion, noise pollution, dust and pest management challenges.
They also highlighted specific concerns about the landfill’s proximity to Dairy Flat School and the Surf Park development. Environmental and health issues were also noted, including airborne contaminants and the effects of the landfill on local water supplies, soil quality, and mental health.
Submitters also expressed disappointment over the delay of promised community amenities following the landfill closure, including planned parks, walking trails, and wildlife sanctuaries.
Another area of contention was the economic implications. Submitters argued that extending the landfill activities will further depress property values and restrict future development opportunities. Criticism was also directed towards Auckland Council, with some submitters expressing their frustration with the council for allowing the situation to develop.
WM customers who submitted pointed out the logistical challenges and additional costs associated with transporting Auckland’s waste to other facilities such as Hampton Downs. Another customer identified the risk of relying on a single regional landfill.
Some submissions supporting Option 1 said that existing WM-operated landfills were the cheapest and simplest solution, as they were already equipped with effective environmental controls, WM said, while those opposed to Option 2 and the Wayby site argued Option 1 could pressure council to meet its 2040 zero waste targets.
In its report WM also provided insights into Option 2, noting that extensive site assessments led them to select the Wayby Valley location for the future ARL facility. It said this decision followed a thorough review, including a pause on Environment Court proceedings to re-examine site options, and that “no alternative sites had emerged through this process”.
Once WM finalises its chosen interim solution and develops a consenting strategy, it says it will undertake further consultation.
De Witte says the Dairy Flat community will have to wait for the company’s final decision before they can decide what their next steps will be.
