Marine – Every scallop counts

Another year has passed since we last had freshly gathered scallops from the Hauraki Gulf on our plates. The Northland and Coromandel scallop fisheries have been closed to recreational and commercial harvest since 2023.

The Minister for Oceans and Fisheries Shane Jones and Fisheries New Zealand are considering reopening a handful of scallop beds in Whangārei Harbour to recreational harvest, as early as November.

While an early reopening is deliciously tempting, decades of overallocation and dredging permitted under the Quota Management System have degraded scallop habitats. Since 2023, we have willingly walked away from a traditional summer activity so these beds could rebuild.

We cannot allow indifferent officials to squander our collective conservation efforts.

Restoring local scallops

Ocean current modelling suggests scallop beds across northeastern New Zealand once formed a single connected network, with larvae drifting between them. The scallops still holding on in Whangārei Harbour could be restocking beds well beyond it – potentially vital for restoring the scallop beds off our local beaches.

Whangārei Harbour is a small part of the wider Northland scallop management area stretching from Ahipara on the north-west coast down to Cape Rodney at Leigh. The Minister has a statutory duty to manage that entire fishery, not just small pockets of perceived abundance within it.

In our September submission (which can be read in full with this story online), LegaSea supported the New Zealand Sport Fishing Council’s recommendation that Whangārei Harbour remains closed to recreational scallop fishing.

The best available information indicates that reopening the harbour is premature, unjustified and unacceptably risky.

The case for reopening rests only on a survey of scallop beds inside the harbour. The wider Northland fishery wasn’t surveyed at all. The 2024 survey showed little recovery across the wider fishery despite two years of closure.

Even within the harbour, the picture is mixed. Preliminary results suggest almost all the scallop biomass sits in three beds, density has decreased, and there are fewer juveniles in the large beds. This matters because scallops are broadcast spawners. They need large numbers of scallops nearby to reproduce successfully. Even in perfect conditions, spawning success varies significantly from year to year.

A short, intensive harvest season is highly risky. The harbour would be the only scallop fishery open on the east coast of the North Island. The few beds holding any abundance could be cleaned out in weeks.

Our submission supports reopening to public harvest once there is evidence of sufficient scallop abundance across the wider Northland area. But when that day comes, we cannot hand our scallop fisheries back to the system that emptied them. We need a new approach; one that puts abundance first, bans dredging and removes the private quota rights that make it hard for a Minister to act when a fishery starts to slide.

We can’t wait to be back in the water gathering scallops. We are, however, prepared to wait a couple more years if it means a healthy scallop fishery for our kids and grandkids.

Link to: Whangarei-scallop-submission-recreational-Sept26